Skip to content

Richmond Hill Returns Entire Council as Complete Election-Night Count Shows Incumbent Sweep

All nine sitting members of Richmond Hill Council retain their seats in the completed election-night count, though the City has not yet certified the results.

By City Desk

RICHMOND HILL — October 27, 2026. Mayor David West, both Regional and Local Councillors and all six ward councillors have won their races according to the completed unofficial count from Monday’s municipal election. All 21 of 21 tabulators are reporting, but the City continues to label the results unofficial pending certification by the City Clerk.

A total of 44,604 voters cast ballots, for a 27.98% turnout among 159,441 eligible voters. The City says that is 3,457 more voters than in the 2022 election, and more than 80% of ballots were cast online.

West returns as mayor; regional incumbents retain both seats

Mayor David West received 36,205 votes (83.55%), far ahead of Domenic Bardari with 5,758 (13.29%) and Holo Devnani with 1,371 (3.16%).

The two Regional and Local Councillor seats also stay with the incumbents. Godwin Chan received 29,674 votes (42.82% of candidate votes) and Joe DiPaola received 26,924 (38.85%). Challenger Marco Coletta received 12,699 (18.33%). Voters could choose up to two candidates in this contest, so the percentages refer to votes recorded for candidates, not proportions of individual voters.

All six ward incumbents hold their seats

The completed unofficial count shows very different levels of support across the ward races, from overwhelming majorities to contests decided by comparatively small pluralities.

WardIncumbentVotesVote share
1Carol Davidson3,69644.20%
2Scott Thompson1,92135.17%
3Castro Liu5,74185.67%
4Simon Cui2,94933.44%
5Karen Cilevitz2,10629.95%
6Michael Shiu5,23772.68%

Ward 4 offers the closest three-way contest

In Ward 4, Simon Cui received 2,949 votes (33.44%), only 349 votes ahead of Danny Yoon at 2,600 (29.49%). Rose Weinberg followed with 2,433 (27.59%). Nearly all votes were divided among these three candidates.

In Ward 2, Scott Thompson received 1,921 votes (35.17%), followed by former councillor Tom Muench with 1,403 (25.69%), Muhammad Kermalli with 1,020 (18.67%) and Sigmund Lee with 949 (17.37%). In Ward 1, Carol Davidson received 3,696 (44.20%), ahead of Catherine Dell’Erba with 2,748 (32.86%) and Giovanni Nardone with 1,716 (20.52%).

The leading candidate received less than 50% of votes in four wards: 1, 2, 4 and 5. Under the first-past-the-post system, the candidate with the most votes wins even without an absolute majority.

Ward 5: an unexpected showing

In the eight-candidate Ward 5 contest, Karen Cilevitz received 2,106 votes (29.95%). Richard Rupp placed second with 1,496 (21.28%), and Yuliya Benedziktavich received 1,118 (15.90%).

Benedziktavich did not appear at the candidate events or debates followed by Strong Richmond Hill and did not respond to our email outreach or podcast interview requests. Her 1,118 votes illustrate that participation in such forums is not the only way candidates can attract support. The returns alone cannot show how voters formed their preferences.

More voters than in 2022, same council

According to the City, the 44,604 ballots cast represent 3,457 more voters than in the previous municipal election. Nonetheless, the result at City Hall is continuity: the mayor, both regional councillors and all six ward councillors remain in office for another term, subject to formal certification.

Municipal finance, housing, infrastructure maintenance, transportation and street safety will return to the agenda of the same elected council. Its next term runs from November 15, 2026, to November 14, 2030.

Results note (updated October 27): This article uses the City’s completed election-night count, updated October 26 at 9:42 p.m., with 21 of 21 tabulators reporting. These figures remain unofficial until certified by the City Clerk. The City has said official results will be posted when certification is complete.

💬 What do you think? Join the conversation on STRH Feed

STRH Feed is our community discussion space. Click through to see what others are saying and add your voice.

Tags: